Markets are supposedly “data-driven,” but in reality? Narratives eat data for breakfast.
Think of 2021: meme stocks. The data screamed overvaluation. The narrative (“we’re fighting Wall Street!”) screamed louder. Guess which won?
In this deep dive:
- Dot-com bubble (1990s–2000): Valuations soared not because of balance sheets but because everyone bought into “the Internet will change everything.” Spoiler: the Internet did change everything — but not in the way Pets.com shareholders hoped.
- 2008 housing crash: The data (debt-to-income ratios, NINJA loans) was there, but the narrative was “housing always goes up.” That story drowned out the spreadsheets until the bubble popped.
- Bitcoin’s 2017 run: Fundamentals were shaky, scaling debates unresolved. But the narrative of “digital gold” carried BTC to $20k. The story was stronger than the metrics — at least for a while.
Why Our Brains Prefer Stories
Neuroscience has shown humans are wired for story. Raw data is noise; a good narrative is melody. Investors latch onto tales of disruption, inevitability, justice, or survival. It’s why bubbles inflate and crashes feel like Greek tragedies.
Kahneman calls it narrative fallacy. Our brains need coherence, so we invent it. Investors are less quants and more poets with spreadsheets.
How to Use This Power (Without Being Used by It)
- Ride early: Narratives are like waves. If you spot one building before the crowd, you can surf it.
- Exit before the crash: Don’t confuse narrative with reality. When data and story diverge too far, gravity wins.
- Craft your own narrative: Think like a portfolio storyteller. What arc does your portfolio tell? Is it “tech dominator,” “dividend protector,” “contrarian explorer”? Investors (and you) will believe it more if the story is coherent.
If you read my Day 5 post on guitar tuning, this is the same riff at a different tempo. Narratives are distortion pedals. They make the same old notes sound new.
And here’s the kicker: markets aren’t efficient calculators. They’re stages where stories duel for dominance. Ignore this, and you’ll keep getting blindsided by “irrational” moves. Respect it, and you’ll see the invisible script.
✨ Final note: Narratives don’t just move markets. They move people. And that means they move you. Before you buy or sell, ask: “Am I reacting to data — or to a story so good I can’t help but believe it?”
Leave a Reply